“A Pitched Battle”: The Ainsworth-Windham Fracas of 1903

Recently, in a comment posted to Yvonne Bivins’ essay on the Ainsworth-Smith-Knight family of Smith County, Mississippi. a reader mentioned an infamous neighborhood battle of the early nineteenth century that involved several members of the Ainsworth clan. Reminiscent of stories that abound in popular literature about the feuding Hatfields and McCoys, or, closer to home, the Sullivans of Smith County’s Sullivan’s Hollow, the Ainsworth-Windham feud ranks with the “best” in its portrayal of stereotypical Southern mayhem. My thanks to Yvonne for providing Renegade South with the transcript of this story. 

Vikki Bynum, Moderator

From the Ainsworth Trading Post

Smith County Reformer Raleigh, Mississippi Thursday, February 26, 1903

 A PITCHED BATTLE

Of all the horrible battles into which Satan has ever had the pleasure of leading his forces, there never was one as far as our memory serves us in the history of the county of Smith, which breathes a more Satanic odor or beats a more demonical aspect than the one fought at the Jeffrey Ainsworth old place in the Southeastern part of Smith County near the line of Jasper county on last Saturday evening. We have heard of wars and rumors of war, but this was the biggest war ever fought on Smith county soil. This was a battle in which A.L. (Coon) Ainsworth and his two sons, Jesse and Sloney Ainsworth were arrayed against Anse Windham, in particular, and the other Windhams in general. It is claimed that over 100 gun and pistol shots were fired in this battle, in which Coon Ainsworth and his two sons, Jesse and Sloney were literally riddled with balls. The wounds are so severe that the victims are not expected to recover there from. No other human flesh was penetrated by balls except Anse Windham was slightly wounded in the side after he had emptied his six shooter and was retreating from the battleground in double-quick time.

It is remarkable that no more damage was done in the midst of such an array of balls flying hither and tether, cutting holes through the raiment of many persons and especially that of the Windhams. While human flesh was spared to a seemingly miraculous degree, yet the flesh of the dumb animals were not entirely spared. One horse, one yoke of oxen and a few dogs passed through the ordeal of this historical battle with many marks on their carcasses. This row or riot began at the close of a session of justice court presided over by Justice Andrew Bryant of Beat 2, in which Anse Windham had been proceeded against by Coon Ainsworth’s daughter in a case of bastardy which procedure resulted in the justice binding the accused over in a bond of $1000 to appear at the next term of circuit court to answer the complaint. It is said at this junction Coon Ainsworth kicked over the table, threw the justice docket out at the door and cursed out the justice of the peace, forbade any of the Windhams going on the bond and made an attack on Anse Windham and from that shooting began furiously. It is true that the enormity of the offense which Anse Windham had committed against the Ainsworth family and himself was enough to incense their feelings against his conduct beyond human utterance; for a man to seduce his sister-in-law in this way is wicked to the extreme. But one wrong can’t be corrected by committing another wrong, therefore Coon Ainsworth was not justifiable in letting the case go to trial and then tank up on mean whiskey and cause the shedding of so much blood. These two families of Ainsworths and Windhams related by blood as well as by affinity – hence the feud. Anse, Bill, Hiram, D. Windham and Jim Ainsworth, one of Y.E. Ainsworth’s sons, were brought in Tuesday by N.B. Boykin and G.M. Martin and committed to jail. They will have a preliminary trial here at Raleigh tomorrow. The committal of crime has reached an alarming point in Smith County and in nearly every case mean liquor plays a conspicuous part.

Smith County Reformer, Raleigh, Mississippi, Thursday, March 5, 1903

When court convened here last Friday for the preliminary trial of Anse Windham, Bill Windham and Jim Ainsworth, their cases were dismissed by the court for want of a prosecutor, and the defendants discharged. After that affidavits were made charging Anse and Bill Windham with the murder of Sloney Ainsworth; Anse and Bill Windham for assault and battery with intent to kill A.L. Ainsworth; Anse and Bill Windham for an assault with intent to kill Jesse Ainsworth; papers were issued for their arrest and preliminary trial set to be tried before A.L. Jones at Raleigh today. [final sentence unintelligible]

Smith County Reformer, Raleigh, Mississippi, Thursday, March 26, 1903

Dr. Hill, the attending physician, informs us that Coon Ainsworth who was so severely wounded at Ainsworth’s Store in the unfortunate shooting aggray which occurred on the 21st February 1903, with the Windhams, is improving and is likely to recover. He was shot in different places, but the wound made through the stomach is the most dangerous and difficult to manage. Jesse Ainsworth has about recovered from his wounds. It will be remembered that Sloney Ainsworth died from his wounds which he received at the same time about a week after the lamentable affray.

 

Categories: Uncategorized

13 replies »

  1. First off I just want to say that your blog is fantastic. I have only come to it recently, but I am already captivated. I have been working through the back catalogue, and I particularly enjoyed the profile on Blanche K. Bruce. So many great details.

    I write to you because I am involved with a movie called “Saving Lincoln.” I thought you might be particularly interested because a Virginian is the subject of our movie.

    It tells Lincoln’s story through the eyes of Ward Hill Lamon. The movie is Directed by Salvador Litvak, who invented a filming process called CineCollage in order to make the movie on an indie budget. The tentative release date is Lincoln’s birthday this coming February.

    I would really appreciate it if you took a look at our teaser trailer http://www.savinglincoln.com/ and our Veterans Day tribute http://is.gd/XNQMi8.

    I would love to hear any comments you may have. Maybe we can find a way to drive our respective supporters toward each others projects in a mutually beneficial way. I hope all is well, and keep up the great work!

  2. I still own the property homesteaded by Coon Ainsworth’s brother, Asberry, my great great grandfather. They were the sons of Samson and half brother’s of the children of Samson and his mulatto slave, Martha, ancestors of Mrs. Yvonne Bivins. I read about this fued a couple of years ago. My parents which are both decended from Asberry Ainsworth have no knowledge of the fued. My mother is 87 and has a very good memory, so I suppose it was something that was not passed down. However Coon, my parents great uncle,shot his neighbor, my mother’s grandfather, Levi Allen on his front porch. Levi Allen died later in 1907 from the wound. Mother doesn’t know of any legal action taken against Coon. This took place in Old Taylorsville, a route out of Summerland. If my memory is correct, Anse Windham was married to Coon’s daughter and took advantage of her sister, another daughter of Coon. Anse took his wife and moved to West Monroe and raised their family. There was another killing of one of the Windhams shortly after this fued, while in route either to or from Bay Springs by an unknown assailant.

    • Thanks, Mitchell, for sharing this story! Perhaps others can contribute what they’ve heard. It’s interesting how these stories are–or are not–passed down through the generations.

      Vikki

  3. Thanks for sharing this! I am a descendant of the Windham family and this gives a more personal view of the family.

  4. I am also descendant of Anse Windham. He was my father’s grandfather. My father is also named Anse Windham. He was born and raised in West Monroe, Louisiana where several of his siblings still live.

    • Linda, Coon Ainsworth was my gg grandfather’s brother. A couple of years ago I located Wonderous Ainsworth’s only daughter. She was raised in West Monroe and has asked me about some of the Windham’s that moved to West Monroe that she remember from 50 years ago. She remembers a mother and her sons. I’ve have to call her to get the names again, but it was the same family. Her Dad told her they were related.

      • It would be nice to put them in touch with each other. My Dad still visits his sisters in West Monroe and there is a family reunion in October every year.

  5. Linda Long, I just spoke with the Ainsworth girl that has fond memories of Bryceland Windham. His brother was Breland and sister, Helen and Mother, Vallie. She would love to make contact if this is your family. Friend me on facebook and I will set it up.

  6. Coon Ainsworth was my mother’s grandfather. Her father was Lafayette Ainsworth who settled in Bay Springs, MS. If anyone has any more information about this fued, I would appreciate you letting me know. My mother used to talk about it all the time. Grandpaw Coon was born February 29. And he always called himself a “Blue Hen Chicken”.

    • Sandra Adams, I just looked and saw where my great grandpa Levi Allen lived inbetween Albert L. (Coon) and Lafayette Ainsworth. Layfayette next door and Coon two doors down, in 1900. Have you ever heard of Coon shooting my grandpa Allen? I’ve like to hear anything you know. I was told this by my Aunt that has passed away now. I understand Coon shot him on his front porch, but grandpa Allen died later from an abscess…….??

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s